Wake up, America!


RELATED QUOTES
"Cognitive dissonance is a psychological state that describes the uncomfortable feeling between what one holds to be true and what one knows to be true. In simple terms, it can be the filtering of information that conflicts with what one already believes, in an effort to ignore that information and reinforce one's beliefs" -dictionary
"And there is distrust in Washington. I am surprised, frankly, at the amount of distrust that exists in this town. And I'm sorry it's the case, and I'll work hard to try to elevate it."
-George W. Bush
"If America ever passes out as a great nation, we ought to put on our tombstone: America died from a delusion she had Moral Leadership. -Will Rogers
"We must rapidly begin the shift from a 'thing-oriented' society to a 'person-oriented' society. When machines and computers, profit motives and property rights are considered more important than people, the giant triplets of racism, materialism, and militarism are incapable of being conquered." -Martin Luther King
"And yet America still means hope. Within the 'world' that is America as it actually is, there lies what America means. We are naive only when we confuse the two, when our feeling of hope is directed toward the outer America that we percieve with the senses, rather than the America we grasp with the mind and the heart. Because this other America seems powerless or elusive does not mean it is not real. Because America betrays its ideals is no reason to reject the ideals themselves. We do not live in correspondence with the great life hidden within us; but that is no reason to deny that this hidden life exists and calls to us." -Jacob Needleman
So, once again I'm back in the U S of A and undergoing reverse culture shock. It's actually a pleasant process, and the effects of jet lag tinge it with just the right degree of unreality. In this cultural halfway-house state of being, both food and communication become engaging experiences.
The menu choices in restaurants, the meal options in a supermarket, and even the candy selection in a convenience store remind my tastebuds of long untapped pleasures.
Communication now includes the potential for more subtle realms such as humor, idiom and innuendo; levels not so easily reached when I'm conversing in Thai.
I also notice the conversations of strangers who are in close enough proximity. Rather than offering voyeuristic satisfaction, this proves to be an irritating invasion of my own mental wanderings. I realize that I have come to appreciate the white noise of rapidly spoken Thai as a background to my inner musings.
I am once more immersed in American buildings, American culture, and, well, Americans. I am back in familiar territory. Less exotic, and better understood. Breathe deeply, Dorothy. You're back in Kansas.
And, given the year, month and situation, I am surounded by an ongoing presidential primary. That is the catalyst for this topic, and I confess that the combination of returning from overseas and this current political campaign has led me to disquieting reflections. I will attempt to share some of these thoughts, rather than defend them. Politics and nationalism strike emotional chords in many people, and the intent here is to express rather than persuade.
The first quote in this blog was a definition of cognitive dissonance. Let me offer another, this one from the American Heritage Dictionary: cognitive dissonance: A condition of conflict or anxiety between one's beliefs and one's actions, such as opposing the slaughtering of animals and eating meat.
Or, a belief that America is a just and compassionate nation, while also acknowledging the abuses in Guantanamo, the collateral deaths of children in Afghanistan and Iraq, our economic opposition to combat global warming... It takes a lot of rationalization to reconcile America's actions with her alleged values, and I think that far too many people are managing that rationalization far too well. As a collective nation we have become numb to the pain in the world and numb to the consquences of our government's actions.
We also, by use of our economic and military strength, employ a double standard that we would indignantly refuse to accept from others.
Am I anti-American? No, there is much about this country that I love and cherish. But that is not a reason to remain obligingly silent or to respond with knee-jerk defensiveness. If a child exhibits behaviors which are dangerous to itself or others, does a parent look the other way out of love?
Am I a patriot? This is a more complicated question. and provokes a less definitive response. I am a patriot of America's ideals, but not of my country's government and practices. And I do not say this proudly, but rather sadly, with a genuine sense of loss.
It is not that other countries are better. The subjugation of women in the name of god, blatant corruption, horrendous abuse of individual rights, political posturing over humane government, economic greed prioritized over human need. . . . I don't see many shining role models out there.
Still. . . . Maybe I was just brainwashed and naive, but I expected better from America.
How has our government reached the place where I now see it? Offhand, three thoughts come to mind.
One, I think we have become a nation of consumers. Arguably not a bad thing in itself, but we have become enamored of goods to the point of forsaking our goodness. I fear we are a nation of idealists in words, but a nation of materialists in our actions. "The most pitiful among men is he who turns his dreams into silver and gold." -Kahlil Gibran
Two, I think that many of us are accepting the decisions of our politicians out of fear. Agreed, it is a scarey world out there. But unilateral action, anticipatory strikes and 'acceptable' collateral damage does not make us safer in the long run. Our bombs are creating new generations of terrorists, just as our past policies have contributed to to the current terrorist threat. I hope you do not misinterpret my words. I am not saying that terrorism is justified. Understanding someone's actions is not the same as condoning them.
Along the same reasoning, I understand the fear of Americans which allows them to see children killed abroad and our civil liberties under attack at home. But again, understanding is not the same as condoning.
The third point is not so easily conveyed in a bullet paragraph. I believe that America is not just a creator of the world we live in, but is a product of that world as well. Logistical and technological complexities have evolved farther than our personal consciousness. In some ways, the misdeeds of America are less a condemnation of the country than a reflection of the present level of humankind's social and spiritual evolution.
The question to ask, ultimately, is what should we do next? There are no easy answers, but I believe we need to move forward with both our hearts and our heads. Neither alone will suffice.
First off, in the coming elections, are you going to be voting out of fear or out of hope?
We need to examine the actions of our country both carefully and critically; neither with unthinking patriotism nor with whining and self-righteous condemnation.
We need a different criteria for success other than the largest house, the biggest car and the most possesions.
As a nation and as individuals we need to examine both our motivations and our reasons for them. An honest examination; not just a reciting of our old scripts.
It is true that the price of freedom is not cheap. But the implication that our freedom has to be defended by blood is not nearly the whole picture. Freedom comes at the cost of honest self-appraisal. More often than giving up our lives, freedom requires that we give up our assumptions.
With rhetoric replacing reality and expediency replacing equality, the American dream is becoming just that; a dream. We have a vision to live up to that has fallen into disrepair, and ideals that are worthy of our vigilance.
Wake up, America






