A Different Kind of Schadenfreude, Part 2


To briefly recount: one of my memories of my first month in Yellowstone was of being utterly charmed by the decayed rusticity of places like Gardiner. But as I walked through the town, I found myself looking again at the vehicles, the worn-out pickups and nearly dead Ford LTDs, Mafia Staff Cars from the late 1970s, which is a long time ago now. I looked again at the stuff in peoples' back yards (the town does put forth a relatively attractive face): the old horse trailer with a flat tire, the oil drums, the stacks of rotting lumber and pieces of even older cars. I looked again at the architecture, by means of which one can gaze back through the decades: from recent commercial kitsch back through the tourist boom of the 1950s and all the way to the original tourist boom of the late 19th century. And I came to understand--perhaps not for the first time, but for the first time with any force--that what had looked charming to me before looked like rural poverty now.
Not that Gardiner is really "poor." The town is unusual because it has been a tourist destination since before it was even founded. But it is not wealthy, and other places in Montana do not have Yellowstone National Park to live on, and so are even harder pressed. This opinion is not just based on personal impression. According to the Census Bureau, at the time we made the trip I am about to describe, per capita personal income in Montana was 47th in the nation (it has come up a little since then, but no one can tell me if that is merely the effect of having a couple of software billionaires buy houses in the state). This distress is a consequence of having an economy that is largely based on agriculture, lumber, and mining--basically a 19th century economy, one that will never grow very rapidly. And you can see the effects in the lines on people's faces.
A year earlier, during our annual extended visit to Yellowstone, we found ourselves in a Chinese restaurant in one of the gateway communities outside the park. The tabletops were sticky, the floors were sticky, the restroom door was blocked permanently by a stack of cardboard boxes, a ceiling fan languidly stirred the flies. I was quite happy with the place, and we fed the family for about sixty cents.
"What a beautiful child!"
A customer, seated nearby, was commenting on Lewis, who was then about a year old. He was insanely cute, so we were used to this sort of remark. I turned to acknowledge the compliment.
It had come from a woman who sat with her husband or boyfriend, eating what seemed to be boiled carp. Her man looked like Hulk Hogan, only he weighed about ninety-eight pounds. The woman looked neither healthy nor wealthy. She smiled. Half her teeth were missing. The other half looked like the fossilized teeth of the dinosaurs they dig up in eastern Montana.
At this moment, I went into a Jekyll-and-Hyde conflict. I have two brains, a home-brain and a Yellowstone-brain. The first is guarded, suspicious, easily annoyed; the second, as you might suspect, is a whole lot mellower. We had been in the region for a few days, so I was balanced on the fulcrum point between the two, right on the verge of tipping over into the ramshackle serenity of Yellowstone. My first thought, when I saw her missing teeth and deeply-lined face, was "methamphetamines." I was assuming she had meth mouth, the tooth decay that comes of amphetamine abuse. I went on alert.
And then Lewis smiled. He had about as many teeth as the woman did, with the same wide gaps. He smiled because he was a baby, not because he was a great judge of character, but he broke my train of thought. My earlier judgment, I decided, was stupid. The woman--still smiling--was too big for amphetamines, and actually looked nothing like an addict. The gravest meth epidemic, I knew perfectly well, rages among journalists writing stories about meth epidemics. It's a big-city prejudice: the urbanite assumes that country folk, along with their mullet haircuts and house trailers, have all got amphetamine habits. At that moment, I slipped into my Yellowstone self. I smiled, as I always do when people compliment Lewis. I do, at least, have pretty much all of my teeth.
One sees a lot of missing teeth in the Northern Rockies, as in other rural regions. It results from a lack of dentistry added to physically tough jobs and sometimes violence. Take ranching as an example; you don't come away unhurt after spending all day for years on end forcing obstinate horses to force obstinate cattle to their doom. Of course, the economy of the West has changed, and the busboys outnumber the cowboys now, but the old economy is still there; sometimes it lives hidden behind the new West, and sometimes the two live in a makeshift partnership (if you've seen it, recall the movie City Slickers, where the beef ranchers use their New York dude customers to move their herd). We tend to love a place the most if it is "authentic" and not "touristy," but in the rural West, an authentic place is one with that 19th century economy I was talking about. Gold mining sounds romantic; so does being a lumberjack or a cowboy. The reality is hard on the knees and back and everything else, and dependence on these ancient extractive models has kept economic opportunity limited in some of the same ways they were when Ulysses Grant signed the bill that created Yellowstone park.
There is probably more to it, cultural differences that keep the region from changing too much. In a place like the Northern Rockies, personal appearance can be almost unbelievably informal; a bylaw of the local culture states that looking like a woods hermit, or even being one, is acceptable here. I have always had the impression that most Montanans--except businesspeople--would not want the place to change in the ways necessary to turn it into another Texas or California. And there are, of course, vast advantages to such attitudes. People in the Northern Rockies are not slaves to fashion and ostentatious display the way Texans and Californians are; if and when they do sell their birthrights, they seem to spend the money more wisely. When I took that walk in Gardiner, I noted something else that was lacking: expensively manicured lawns. Here was wisdom; the locals had decided to forego the thousands of dollars and hundreds of hours' work that the green tyrants demand. "You don't have a lawn," the saying goes. "The lawn has you."
There is no easy solution to these problems. There may be no solution at all. In the meantime, people limp along as they always have, turning the failed general store--once a saddler's shop, a hundred years ago--into a gourmet coffee place and internet café that might or might not fly.
When I first came to Yellowstone, long ago, I think I believed that the people here liked living in poverty. What I can now no longer ignore is that people like having all their teeth.




